Ron Paul: No (Internet Sales) Taxation Without Representation

(RPI Opinion) — Last week the United States Supreme Court, in the case of South Dakota v. Wayfair, ruled that the Constitution’s Commerce Clause allows state governments to force out-of-state businesses to collect state sales taxes. This decision overturns the court’s precedent that a state could require only businesses with a “physical presence” in the state to comply with state tax laws.

Unless Congress exercises its authority under the Commerce Clause to counter this decision with legislation, retailers will have to calculate sales taxes on every online purchase. An error in calculating sales taxes could cause a small retailer to undergo a costly and time-consuming audit, or even audits by multiple state governments. The compliance costs, along with the sales taxes themselves, will raise the cost of online commerce, burdening consumers and limiting the growth of internet business.

The burdens imposed on online commerce by the court’s decision will fall particularly hard on smaller internet retailers that rely on online sales to stay open. Stifling the growth of smaller and new internet retailers may be bad for consumers, but it serves the interest of large brick-and-mortar retailers, as well as large online retailers that already have to comply with state sales taxes because they have a physical presence in most states. These large businesses support giving states new taxing powers because they wish to use government power to make sure their smaller competitors stay small.

Allowing states to tax internet retailers with no physical presence in their states — and thus limited influence over state legislators — violates the principle of no taxation without representation. Tax- and power-hungry politicians will likely use this new power not just to increase taxes, but to impose other tax and regulatory burdens on out-of-state businesses. Having the power to tax and regulate employers and workers who cannot retaliate at the polls is a dream come true for many politicians. By making almost all online purchases subject to sales taxes, the decision will also reduce pressure on states to keep sales tax rates low.

The Constitution’s drafters intended the Commerce Clause to create free trade among the states, not to enable states to impose taxes and regulations on out-of-state businesses. The growth of online commerce does not change the Commerce Clause’s purpose.

Allowing state governments to force out-of-state retailers to comply with state tax laws harms small businesses, harms the growth of online commerce, and raises prices. It also benefits politicians seeking new tax revenue and helps large, politically-powerful corporations.

Congress must protect consumers, taxpayers, and small businesses by passing legislation limiting states’ ability to extend their taxing power across their borders. This would be a rare instance of Congress using its Commerce Clause powers for the intended purpose of promoting free trade among the states, not enabling the growth of government.

Opinion by Ron Paul / Republished with permission / RPI / Report a typo

This article was chosen for republication based on the interest of our readers. Anti-Media republishes stories from a number of other independent news sources. The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not reflect Anti-Media editorial policy.

Since you’re here…
…We have a small favor to ask. Fewer and fewer people are seeing Anti-Media articles as social media sites crack down on us, and advertising revenues across the board are quickly declining. However, unlike many news organizations, we haven’t put up a paywall because we value open and accessible journalism over profit — but at this point, we’re barely even breaking even. Hopefully, you can see why we need to ask for your help. Anti-Media’s independent journalism and analysis takes substantial time, resources, and effort to produce, but we do it because we believe in our message and hope you do, too.

If everyone who reads our reporting and finds value in it helps fund it, our future can be much more secure. For as little as $1 and a minute of your time, you can support Anti-Media. Thank you. Click here to support us

Related Posts

Why You Should Be Skeptical of Everything You Hear About the Iran Protests

Comments Off on Why You Should Be Skeptical of Everything You Hear About the Iran Protests

That One Time Hillary Removed Trump’s Favorite Terror Cult From the Terrorist List

Comments Off on That One Time Hillary Removed Trump’s Favorite Terror Cult From the Terrorist List

Putin Claims US Intelligence Agents Funneled $400 Million to Clinton Campaign

Comments Off on Putin Claims US Intelligence Agents Funneled $400 Million to Clinton Campaign

Elizabeth Warren Lashes Out at Trump for Mocking the Entire #MeToo Movement

Comments Off on Elizabeth Warren Lashes Out at Trump for Mocking the Entire #MeToo Movement

Abolish ICE Movement Spreads as Activist Encampments Shut Down Multiple Facilities

Comments Off on Abolish ICE Movement Spreads as Activist Encampments Shut Down Multiple Facilities

Supreme Court Ruling Gives Any President a Blank Check to Detain American Citizens

Comments Off on Supreme Court Ruling Gives Any President a Blank Check to Detain American Citizens

Memo to the President Ahead of Monday’s Putin Summit

Comments Off on Memo to the President Ahead of Monday’s Putin Summit

California Schools Sued for Putting Kids on Probation for Defying Authority

Comments Off on California Schools Sued for Putting Kids on Probation for Defying Authority

Watch: ICE Whistleblower Interview With CBS Interrupted by Government Agents

Comments Off on Watch: ICE Whistleblower Interview With CBS Interrupted by Government Agents

Leaked Video Shows Detained Children Being Threatened Against Speaking to Press

Comments Off on Leaked Video Shows Detained Children Being Threatened Against Speaking to Press

America’s Largest Supermarket Chain to Test Driverless Grocery Deliveries

Comments Off on America’s Largest Supermarket Chain to Test Driverless Grocery Deliveries

Create Account



Log In Your Account