The Essential Difference Between Liberty-Lovers and Big-Government Types Is Political Tolerance

The Essential Difference Between Liberty-Lovers and Big-Government Types Is Political Tolerance

Comments Off on The Essential Difference Between Liberty-Lovers and Big-Government Types Is Political Tolerance

By Daniel J. Mitchell

As long as it’s voluntary, free-market supporters are happy to let others experiment with socialism. The opposite does not hold true.

Why are there so few liberty-oriented societies compared to the number of places with statist governments?

And why does it seem like the size and scope of government keeps expanding around the world?

If I’m feeling optimistic, I’ll disagree with the tone of those questions. There are reasons to be cheerful, after all. the Soviet Empire collapsed and there’s solid data that global economic liberty has increased over the past few decades. And for those who care about evidence, there’s a slam-dunk argument that smaller government means more prosperity.

But if I’m feeling pessimistic, I’ll look at grim numbers suggesting that the burden of government automatically will expand because of demographic change. And I also worry about eroding societal capital, with more and more people thinking it’s okay to live off the government. And let’s not forget “public choice,” the theory that explains why politicians have an incentive to make government bigger.

Why Decentralization Is Important

I go back and forth on whether the glass is half full or half empty, and I’m not sure which side is winning. All I can say for sure is that Americans are getting increasingly polarized as we have big fights about the proper role of government.

It is why I’ve always thought decentralization would be a good idea. Not just for policy reasons, but also for domestic tranquility. All the leftists could move to places such as CaliforniaIllinois, and New Jersey and vote themselves Greek-style government. And all the advocates of limited government could move to more laissez-faire states such as New HampshireTexas, and South Dakota.

We don’t need a national divorce, not even the humorous version. We just need Swiss-style federalism.

But statists will never agree to that approach. And these two sentences from Reddit’Libertarian page succinctly explain the left’s opposition.

This guy nails it.

The Inherent Difference

Libertarians have no objection to a bunch of statists creating some sort of socialist or communist mini-society, so long as it’s voluntary. Indeed, we’ve periodically had experimental societies in America based on Marxist principles. Starting with the Pilgrims (who learned from their mistake). And I still laugh every time I think about Bernie Sanders getting ejected from a hippie commune because he was too lazy to do his share of the common work.

But this tolerance isn’t a two-way street. Libertarians will let socialists create statist systems inside a free society, but the left won’t allow libertarian outposts in statist societies.

Activist Post Daily Newsletter



Subscription is FREE and CONFIDENTIAL

Free Report:
How To Survive The Job Automation Apocalypse with subscription

Related Posts

Animal rights group decries conditions at turkey farm

Comments Off on Animal rights group decries conditions at turkey farm

Scott Pruitt had penchant for travel before becoming EPA chief

Comments Off on Scott Pruitt had penchant for travel before becoming EPA chief

Mitt Romney is back — and a problem for Trump that could get worse

Comments Off on Mitt Romney is back — and a problem for Trump that could get worse

Harvard upholds 2016 rule against single-gender social clubs

Comments Off on Harvard upholds 2016 rule against single-gender social clubs

Working too long can be unhealthy — and fatal

Comments Off on Working too long can be unhealthy — and fatal

Senator will introduce bill that would send illegal border crossers immediately back to home country

Comments Off on Senator will introduce bill that would send illegal border crossers immediately back to home country

New negligence cases filed on behalf of 450+ Las Vegas shooting victims

Comments Off on New negligence cases filed on behalf of 450+ Las Vegas shooting victims

Stolen Edgar Degas painting found in luggage on bus

Comments Off on Stolen Edgar Degas painting found in luggage on bus

Reports: Police called to investigate burglary at Gronk’s home

Comments Off on Reports: Police called to investigate burglary at Gronk’s home

2017 “Food Issue” recipe index

Comments Off on 2017 “Food Issue” recipe index

The funniest wildlife photos of 2017

Comments Off on The funniest wildlife photos of 2017

Republicans are ‘bought’ by NRA, new ads from gun safety group contend

Comments Off on Republicans are ‘bought’ by NRA, new ads from gun safety group contend

Create Account



Log In Your Account